A judge on Tuesday ordered Microsoft to stop selling Microsoft Word products
in their current form in the U.S., but legal appeals or technical work-arounds
make an actual halt of sales unlikely.
The U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas gave Microsoft 60 days
to comply with the injunction, which forbids Microsoft from selling Word
products that let people create custom XML documents, according to i4i. The
ruling, which also includes additional damages Microsoft must pay, is related to
a patent infringement suit filed by i4i.
[ Stay ahead of the key tech business news with InfoWorld's Today's Headlines:
First Look newsletter and InfoWorld Daily podcast. ]
The most common versions of Word on the market now, 2003 and 2007, both allow
users to create custom XML documents.
Microsoft did not reply to questions about the affect the injunction will have
on it and its ability to sell Word in the U.S. In a statement it said it planned
to appeal the verdict.
An appeal could stay the injunction but even if the injunction stands, Microsoft
could potentially strip the functionality from Word or possibly build a
work-around.
The ruling is unlikely to affect anyone any time soon, said Michael Cherry, an
analyst with Directions on Microsoft. "It's going to take a long time for this
kind of thing to get sorted out," he said.
Custom XML allows people to create forms or templates such that words in certain
fields are tagged and then can be managed in a database, said Loudon Owen, a
spokesman for i4i. Large companies and government agencies, for example, might
create such templates.
I4i's patent covers technology that lets end users manipulate document
architecture and content.
In a March 2007 suit, i4i charged Microsoft with willfully infringing its
patent. Earlier this year, a jury in the Texas court ordered Microsoft to pay
i4i US$200 million for infringing the patent.
Owen said that if the injunction stands, end users who use custom XML in Word
will have to find another way to create templates. "Hopefully you're going to
call us because our intention is to support custom XML," he said.
The judge also ruled that Microsoft should pay an additional $40 million for
willful infringement of the patents and over $37 million in prejudgment
interest. That brings total damages to more than $290 million.